With the award given to CC Sabathia yesterday, numerous Indians fans including Scott Koenning, Liza Spears, and others, have expressed their disappointment and displeasure, and quite understandably. The Tickle City O'-The Week Award Committee hereby offers this message of condolence and intends to further explore the implications of the trade. It's always hard to say goodbye to your popular ace, even more so when he has spent his entire career with your organization. When an exciting Verlander-Sabathia match-up abruptly changes to Verlander-Sowers and you know your reigning AL Cy Young winner is on a plane to his new home, it would be a weak Indians fan not to be angry. Koenning, upset with the news, wrote:
"Today the Brewers swooped in to capitalize on the Cleveland Indians' not so ticklish season and acquired the true hefty lefty (no disrespect to Jared Lorenzen), C.C. Sabathia. Sabathia likely would not have resigned with the Indians, and as such the Tribe's hand was essentially forced into pulling the trigger on a deal to bring in the second coming of the Brewer's own Ryan Braun, Matt LaPorta. While most see this as a lopsided deal favoring the Brewers, the reality of the situation is that the Indians have acquired a great talent for the long term while the Brewers have the services of Sabathia likely only for the duration of the season, and are unlikely to A) resign Sabathia, and B) win the World Series. This makes the winners of the deal the Cleveland Indians.
At this point you might be expecting to see "Matt LaPorta, you are tickle city!" or "Cleveland Front Office, you are tickle city!", but that would be dishonest, because in reality the Brewers have stolen maybe the best pitcher in baseball for an outfield who is currently hitting .288 in Double A ball (albeit with a somewhat ticklish 20 homers and 66 RBIs).
With that said, my relentless optimism for Cleveland sports regardless of the situation, you are tickle city!
Oh, and LeBron is definitely staying in Cleveland. Those Nets rumors are so silly."
Points well taken. It is certainly true that it will be unlikely that the Brewers can sign Sabathia or Ben Sheets after the season, so we are essentially renting CC and preparing to part ways with our own beloved ace, (prove me wrong Benny) while giving up our top prospect in the process. However, this kind of risky move, a very strong surge for the playoff birth we haven't had since 1982, is great to see and exactly the kind of thing the Brewers of old would never have done. Year after year we've been on the other end of the spectrum, trading away our top players (ex. Carlos Lee), and perpetually waiting for next year. It's definitely a risky move by the Brew Crew, but one that's being welcomed whole-heartedly by fans, and it's going to be a great playoff race. LaPorta is a great talent, although somewhat blocked in the Brewers organization, and it's good to see him go somewhere where he should be able to make a positive impact in the not distant future. Zach Jackson can pitch a bit, too, and the Brewers still have a bunch of promising young bats down in Huntsville and Nashville. As for Lebron, I think the NBA as a whole risks losing him to a career as a defense lawyer. I can't believe he still won the case without even using the documents that proved his client's innocence. CC Sabathia, prepare to tickle the Colorado Rockies!